Allowance or Expectation? The Chore Debate Every Parent Faces

In partnership with

How old is your body? Find your biological age.

Are you ageing faster than normal? We’ll help you answer that.

Find your body’s true age
Track what’s causing aging
Personalised insights into slowing it down

70% of Superpower members lower their biological age.

Find your biological age in 5 minutes for free.

Take the Quiz

The Pros, Cons, and Smart Alternatives for Teaching Responsibility

Chores. Allowance. Earning money.

Put those three words in the same sentence and you’ll spark a debate in any group of parents — especially those of us who want to raise money-smart, hard-working kids.

Should you pay your kids for doing chores?
Some say yes — it teaches work ethic.
Others say no — kids should contribute simply because they’re part of the family.

As a dad who talks a lot about money and parenting, here’s my take — and some smart alternatives to consider if you're stuck in the middle.

💰 The Case For Paying for Chores

Let’s start with the arguments in favor of tying chores to cash.

✅ 1. It Teaches the Value of Work

When kids see that effort = earnings, they begin to understand a fundamental truth about money:
It’s earned, not given.

Getting paid for completing a task builds a connection between labor, discipline, and reward — a mindset that can carry into their future jobs, businesses, and responsibilities.

✅ 2. It Creates Teachable Moments

Allowance tied to chores gives you natural opportunities to talk about:

• Saving vs. spending

• Earning extra for going above and beyond

• Delayed gratification

• Budgeting and goal setting

It transforms money from an abstract concept to something they feel and manage.

✅ 3. It Encourages Initiative

Want your kid to ask, “Is there anything else I can do to earn more?”
Paying for chores — especially optional ones — gives kids a sense of control and motivation.

🚫 The Case Against Paying for Chores

Now for the other side of the coin.

❌ 1. It Undermines Family Responsibility

When kids expect payment for every household task, chores stop being about contribution and start being transactional.

You risk raising a child who says:

That mindset doesn’t just hurt the family dynamic — it can bleed into school, friendships, and later, relationships.

❌ 2. It Can Create Power Struggles

If every chore has a dollar attached, what happens when a kid refuses to do it?

• Do they just skip it and accept a smaller allowance?

• Do you threaten punishment on top of no pay?

• Does every chore become a negotiation?

This can backfire fast and erode consistency.

❌ 3. It Sends Mixed Messages About Contribution

When money is the only motivator, the intrinsic value of being a team player gets lost.

Kids may stop doing anything that doesn’t come with a reward, which defeats the purpose of raising responsible, capable adults.

🤝 A Balanced Approach: The Split System

Here’s the model we use in The Money Dad household — and it works beautifully:

👉 Split chores into two categories:

1. Family Responsibilities (Unpaid):
   These are the basics — things every member of the household is expected to do because we’re a team.

   • Making their bed

   • Cleaning up after themselves

   • Helping set the table

   • Doing laundry or feeding the dog

2. Extra Opportunities (Paid):
   These are optional tasks that go above and beyond. Think of them like freelance gigs inside your home.

   • Washing the car

   • Raking leaves

   • Organizing the garage

   • Helping with a home project

This model teaches both responsibility and resourcefulness — without creating entitlement or burnout.

💡 Creative Alternatives to Cash-Based Chores

If you don’t love the idea of paying your kids directly for chores, here are a few smart alternatives:

🏦 1. Point System or “Kid Credits”

Assign point values to chores. Points can be redeemed for privileges like:

• Screen time

• A sleepover

• A favorite outing

• Picking the next family movie

This teaches delayed gratification and decision-making — without always involving cash.

💳 2. Chore Bank or Commission Jar

Set up a family "bank" where kids log completed extra chores and “earn” deposits. You can do a payout once a week (just like a job). This mimics a real-world paycheck system and gives them something to look forward to.

📚 3. Skill-Building Focus

Instead of emphasizing payment, highlight what they're learning:

• “You’re getting great at time management by cleaning your room quickly!”

• “Thanks for organizing the garage — that’s leadership.”

Not every reward has to be money. Sometimes, recognition is the best currency.

👨‍👩‍👧‍👦 Final Thoughts: What Are You Really Teaching?

The goal isn’t to bribe your kids into cleaning.
The goal is to raise financially capable, responsible humans who:

• Contribute to the family

• Understand the value of money

• Know how to earn, save, and manage it

• Aren’t afraid to get their hands dirty when life calls for it

So, should you pay your kids for chores?

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. But if you lead with intention, communicate your expectations clearly, and stay consistent — you’ll win either way.

💬 Your Turn:

Do you pay your kids for chores? Why or why not?
I’d love to hear your approach — reply to the newsletter or drop a comment!

BOOK A DISCOVER CALL: Let’s see if it makes sense to work together

We’re excited to announce The Money Dad Referral Program! Share your unique link with friends and family, and earn exclusive rewards like our Creative Tax Strategies for W2 Employees guide, coaching calls, and more as a thank-you for helping grow our community.