How to Build a Phantom Equity Plan That Motivates Like Stock—Without Giving Away Shares

In partnership with

Tackle your credit card debt by paying 0% interest until nearly 2027

Reduce interest: 0% intro APR helps lower debt costs.
Stay debt-free: Designed for managing debt, not adding.
Top picks: Expert-selected cards for debt reduction.

Learn How To Apply Now

Designing a phantom equity plan for a small business involves creating a way to reward key employees with equity-like incentives—without giving away actual ownership. It's a great option when you want to align incentives, attract or retain talent, and share in the business's success without diluting control.

Here’s a step-by-step guide to designing a phantom equity plan:

🔹 Step 1: Define the Objective

What is the main goal of the plan?

• Retention – Encourage employees to stay longer.
  
  

• Incentivization – Drive performance or growth.
  
  

• Succession Planning – Prepare for a future exit or sale.
  
  

• Reward – Recognize long-time contributions.
  
  

🔹 Step 2: Decide Who’s Eligible

Determine which employees or partners will participate:

• Key executives?
  
  

• Long-term employees?
  
  

• High-performers?
  Create a criteria checklist: tenure, position, performance, etc.
  
  

🔹 Step 3: Determine the Phantom “Equity Pool”

Phantom shares don’t represent real ownership, but you should base them on a percentage of company value or cash payout:

• For example: 10,000 total phantom shares = 10% of company value.
  
  

• You allocate these like stock options.
  
  

🔹 Step 4: Define the Vesting Schedule

Use time-based, performance-based, or hybrid vesting:

• Time-based: 4-year vesting with a 1-year cliff.
  
  

• Performance-based: Vest if revenue hits $X or EBITDA reaches $Y.
  
  

• Hybrid: Mix both (common in small businesses).
  
  

🔹 Step 5: Set the Valuation Method

How will you determine the company's value at payout?

• Fixed valuation (e.g. $5 million based on appraisal).
  
  

• EBITDA multiple (e.g. 4x annual EBITDA).
  
  

• Third-party appraisal annually or at exit.
  
  

• Be transparent and consistent.
  
  

🔹 Step 6: Choose the Trigger Events for Payout

Most phantom equity plans pay out upon specific events:

• Sale of the company
  
  

• Change of control
  
  

• Retirement or termination
  
  

• Annual bonuses (for cash-based plans)
  
  

Lump sum or installment payments? Clarify in the agreement.

🔹 Step 7: Determine Tax Treatment

Phantom equity is usually taxed as ordinary income when paid, not when granted or vested.

• The company deducts the payout as a business expense.
  
  

• Work with a CPA to make sure you're complying with:
  
  

  • IRC Section 409A (deferred compensation rules)
    
    

  • Proper withholding and reporting
    
    

🔹 Step 8: Draft the Legal Plan Document

Include:

• Definitions (phantom shares, valuation, triggers)
  
  

• Vesting schedule
  
  

• Payout terms and timing
  
  

• Conditions for forfeiture (termination, misconduct)
  
  

• Tax and legal disclosures
  
  

• Arbitration/Dispute resolution clause
  
  

Hire an attorney to draft or review the document to avoid future headaches.

🔹 Step 9: Communicate the Plan

Roll it out clearly to eligible team members:

• One-on-one explanation
  
  

• Provide written summaries and FAQs
  
  

• Emphasize it’s not actual equity, but a cash bonus tied to value
  
  

🔹 Step 10: Review Annually

Update valuations, review participant performance, and adjust allocations as the business evolves.

Bonus: Phantom Equity vs Real Equity – Quick Comparison

We’re excited to announce The Money Dad Referral Program! Share your unique link with friends and family, and earn exclusive rewards like our Creative Tax Strategies for W2 Employees guide, coaching calls, and more as a thank-you for helping grow our community.