Why We Make Dumb Money Decisions Even When We Know Better

In partnership with

Feeling stuck, overwhelmed, or unsure if you’re doing the “right” things with your money?

I work one on one with families and business owners to turn financial stress into a simple, confident system. If you want clarity, a plan you actually understand, and accountability that fits real life, personal financial coaching might be your next best step.
Apply here to work with me privately and start building a calmer, more intentional financial life.

[email protected] or reply to this email.

The Cozy Winter Ritual Behind My Energy and Glow ✨

Winter calls for rituals that actually make you feel amazing—and Pique’s Sun Goddess Matcha is mine. It delivers clean, focused energy with zero jitters, supports glowing skin and gentle detox, and feels deeply grounding on cold mornings. Smooth, ceremonial-grade, and crave-worthy, it’s the easiest way to start winter days clear, energized, and glowing from the inside out

Get Up To 20% Off

The Science Behind Bad Financial Habits

Have you ever told yourself, “I know better than this,” right after making a bad money decision?

You knew you shouldn’t swipe the card.

You knew you should have saved that bonus.

You knew the interest rate was brutal.

And yet, you did it anyway.

Here is the truth most people do not talk about:

Bad money decisions are rarely about intelligence. They are about psychology.

As a financial advisor, coach, and dad, I have seen brilliant, capable people sabotage their own financial plans. Not because they are lazy. Not because they are irresponsible. But because they are human.

Let’s break down the science behind why we make dumb money decisions even when we know better.

1. Your Brain Is Wired for Survival, Not Wealth

The human brain evolved to survive immediate threats. It is designed to prioritize short term safety and reward over long term optimization.

When you see something you want, your brain releases dopamine. That chemical does not care about your retirement plan. It cares about feeling good right now.

Spending money activates the same reward pathways as food, social approval, and other pleasures.

Saving for retirement 30 years from now does not.

So when you choose dinner out over investing that $80, your brain is not being dumb. It is doing exactly what it was built to do.

The problem is that our financial lives require long term thinking, while our brains default to short term gratification.

2. Present Bias Is Stronger Than Willpower

There is a behavioral economics concept called present bias. It means we disproportionately value rewards today over rewards in the future.

Ask someone:

Would you rather have $100 today or $120 in a month?

Many choose $100 today, even though waiting is mathematically smarter.

This shows up everywhere in family finance:

• Buying now instead of waiting and saving

• Financing instead of paying cash

• Skipping contributions because “we will start next month”

We are not bad at math. We are biased toward now.

That bias must be engineered around, not ignored.

3. Emotions Drive Most Financial Decisions

We love to think we are rational with money. Research shows the opposite.

Money decisions are emotional first, logical second.

Stress leads to spending.

Boredom leads to scrolling and shopping.

Insecurity leads to lifestyle upgrades.

Fear leads to pulling investments at the worst time.

During market downturns, investors often sell low because fear overwhelms logic. During bull markets, they buy high because optimism feels safe.

The market does not cause these reactions. Our emotions do.

If you do not build systems that protect you from your emotional swings, you will eventually make a decision you regret.

4. Social Comparison Warps Reality

Your brain constantly compares you to others. It is a survival mechanism tied to belonging.

In today’s world, social media amplifies that instinct.

You see:

• The new kitchen

• The luxury vacation

• The upgraded car

• The private school enrollment

And your brain interprets it as a benchmark.

You may know your budget cannot support that lifestyle. But comparison triggers insecurity, and insecurity triggers spending.

Most lifestyle inflation is not driven by need. It is driven by comparison.

The antidote is clarity about your own values, not someone else’s highlight reel.

5. Decision Fatigue Makes You Financially Sloppy

Busy parents make thousands of decisions every day.

Work decisions.

Kid decisions.

Meal decisions.

Schedule decisions.

By the end of the day, your brain is exhausted.

When cognitive energy is low, you default to the easiest option. That usually means:

• Convenience spending

• Skipping the budget review

• Ignoring the credit card statement

• Clicking “buy now”

Willpower is not infinite. It depletes throughout the day.

If your financial plan relies on constant discipline, it will eventually break.

Systems beat willpower every time.

6. Loss Aversion Makes Us Irrational

Psychologists have shown that the pain of losing is about twice as powerful as the pleasure of gaining.

This explains:

• Why people hold onto losing investments too long

• Why they avoid selling a bad decision

• Why they stay in expensive commitments

• Why they refuse to admit a money mistake

The emotional pain of realizing a loss feels worse than the ongoing financial damage.

So we delay. We avoid. We rationalize.

Understanding this bias helps you step back and ask a better question:

If I did not already own this decision, would I make it today?

7. We Overestimate Future Discipline

One of the most dangerous financial lies we tell ourselves is this:

“I will be more disciplined later.”

Later when work slows down.

Later when the kids are older.

Later when income increases.

Behavioral science shows that people consistently overestimate their future self control.

If you struggle to save at $80,000, you will likely struggle at $120,000 unless the system changes.

Income does not fix habits. Structure does.

So What Do We Do About It?

If bad money decisions are wired into human psychology, the answer is not shame. It is design.

Here are practical ways to work with your brain instead of against it:

1. Automate good behavior

Set up automatic investing and saving so discipline is not required monthly.

2. Create friction for bad behavior

Delete saved credit cards. Remove shopping apps. Add a 24 hour pause rule.

3. Use visual progress tracking

Seeing debt shrink or savings grow triggers positive reinforcement.

4. Schedule money meetings

Do not rely on “when I have time.” Put it on the calendar.

5. Define your family’s values

Comparison fades when you know what you actually care about.

Final Thought

You are not bad with money.

You are human with money.

Understanding the science behind your financial habits removes guilt and replaces it with strategy.

The goal is not to become perfectly disciplined. The goal is to build systems that make good decisions easier than bad ones.

That is how families build wealth.

That is how chaos becomes clarity.

And that is how you stop saying, “I knew better,” and start saying, “We built it better.”

If you want help designing money systems that protect your family from emotional mistakes, subscribe to The Money Dad newsletter and start building smarter habits today.

BOOK A DISCOVER CALL: Let’s see if it makes sense to work together

We’re excited to announce The Money Dad Referral Program! Share your unique link with friends and family, and earn exclusive rewards like our Creative Tax Strategies for W2 Employees guide, coaching calls, and more as a thank-you for helping grow our community.